The essentials
Florida surgeon indicted for manslaughter after removing wrong organ in surgical procedure.
A Florida grand jury has indicted Dr. Thomas Shaknovsky on second-degree manslaughter charges following a surgical procedure in which he removed a patient's liver instead of the intended spleen. The patient, identified as 70-year-old Bill Bryan from Alabama, underwent the procedure at a facility in Miramar Beach, Florida.
If convicted, Shaknovsky faces a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison. The indictment marks a formal criminal charge in what authorities are treating as a case of surgical error resulting in serious harm.
Other ways to read this story.
Alternative framings generated by SigNews. These are not independent sources or attributed quotations.
Grand Jury Formal Charge Follows Surgical Complication
The indictment represents the grand jury's formal determination that probable cause exists for second-degree manslaughter charges against Dr. Shaknovsky. This legal proceeding follows the documented surgical incident in which the wrong organ was removed. The maximum 15-year sentence reflects the severity of the charges, establishing the potential consequences should the case proceed to trial and result in conviction.
Surgical Error Results in Criminal Prosecution Framework
The case involves a significant deviation from standard surgical protocol—the removal of a liver instead of a spleen during a planned procedure. Such substantive errors in surgical practice can trigger both civil liability and, as in this case, criminal investigation. The indictment indicates authorities determined the error rose to the level of criminal negligence, distinguishing it from routine medical malpractice claims and entering the criminal justice system.