← All articles

Justices Weigh Whether Late-Arriving Mail Ballots Must Be Counted

The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments on whether states can count mail ballots arriving after Election Day, in a case challenging Mississippi's now-struck-down grace period law. The RNC and Libertarian Party of Mississippi filed the original lawsuits in 2024, and the Trump administration filed an amicus brief opposing late ballot counting. A ruling is expected by June 2026.

AI-assisted reporting

The essentials

The Supreme Court is weighing whether states can count mail ballots received after Election Day, with a ruling due by June 2026.

The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments on the question of whether states may count mail ballots received after Election Day, a case originating in Mississippi.

The dispute stems from lawsuits filed in 2024 by the RNC and the Libertarian Party of Mississippi challenging Mississippi's mail ballot grace period law. The 5th Circuit Court previously struck down that law, and the case has now reached the nation's highest court.

Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch argued before the Court that ballot receipt and counting do not constitute part of the "election" itself — a distinction that could have broad implications for how states define election deadlines. The Trump administration filed an amicus brief siding with the RNC's position against counting late-arriving ballots.

The Court had earlier issued a 7-2 ruling allowing a Republican congressman to sue over Illinois voting rules, a related procedural development. A final decision in the Mississippi case is expected by the end of June 2026.

Broaden the view

Other ways to read this story.

Alternative framings generated by SigNews. These are not independent sources or attributed quotations.

Legal Stakes

Case Could Redefine What Counts as an 'Election'

Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch's argument — that ballot receipt and counting fall outside the legal definition of an "election" — represents a significant interpretive question. If the Court adopts this view, it could affect how states across the country structure mail voting deadlines, potentially limiting grace periods that currently allow ballots postmarked by Election Day to be counted days later.

Party Lines

RNC and Trump Administration Align Against Grace Period

The case has drawn clear partisan positioning: the RNC and the Trump administration both oppose counting ballots received after Election Day, while Mississippi's grace period law had aimed to accommodate voters whose mail-in ballots arrive late. The Libertarian Party of Mississippi joined the RNC's legal challenge, adding a cross-party dimension to the opposition.