Health agencies flag cancer and pollution risks in reintroduced pesticides
Health agencies warn reintroduced pesticides pose cancer and environmental pollution risks.
Event / Politics
Ongoing debate and legislative action regarding the use of neonicotinoid pesticides in France, including reintroduction of previously banned substances and related health and environmental concerns.
2026-08-15 to 2026-11-12 · UTC publication dates
Coverage begins 22 Jul, 09:16 UTC
Follow the documented timeline or explore the related reporting.
On July 20, the French National Assembly voted on a final version of an emergency agricultural bill. The bill includes provisions to reintroduce two previously banned pesticides: acetamiprid and flupyradifurone.
Laurent Alexandre, an Insoumis (La France Insoumise) deputy representing the 2nd constituency of Aveyron, voted against the emergency agricultural bill. He argued the bill does not address urgent agricultural needs including guaranteed remunerative prices, combating unfair competition, and climate change adaptation.
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has determined that acetamiprid, one of the pesticides reintroduced by the French emergency agricultural bill, may provoke cancer. Scientific research also indicates negative effects on children whose mothers were exposed to acetamiprid during pregnancy.
The emergency agricultural bill passed by the National Assembly reintroduces the possibility of using acetamiprid and flupyradifurone, two pesticides previously banned in France. The European Food Safety Authority has raised concerns about the toxicity of these substances.
Flupyradifurone, reintroduced by the French agricultural bill, poses significant environmental risks including the capacity to durably pollute groundwater and degrade water quality. The substance is highly toxic to pollinators, particularly bees, and threatens their survival.
Deputies from La France Insoumise (LFI) and the Greens filed a challenge with France's Constitutional Council on July 24, 2026, contesting multiple provisions of the emergency agricultural law adopted by Parliament on Tuesday. The challenge argues the law violates several constitutional provisions and the Environmental Charter.
The emergency agricultural law permits the food safety agency Anses to authorize acetamipride for hazelnut cultivation and flupyradifurone for sugar beet, apple, and cherry crops for limited durations if specified conditions are met. These pesticides were previously banned as part of EU environmental restrictions.
LFI and Green deputies contend the pesticide provisions were improperly added as a legislative rider with insufficient environmental constraints. They argue the measures fail to adequately limit the geographic scope of pesticide use, were adopted without proper public participation procedures, and contravene protections for biodiversity, pollinators, and birds established by prior Constitutional Council rulings on neonicotinoids.
Deputies argue that the water storage doubling objective should require a programming law rather than ordinary legislation. They also contend the provisions lack general interest justification, benefiting only a small minority of irrigating farmers, and claiming such installations will worsen drought and reduce water access for other users in violation of environmental protection principles.
The Constitutional Council must render its decision on the challenged emergency agricultural law within 30 days of receiving the challenge filed July 24, 2026.
The law establishes an objective to double the volume of water storage for agricultural irrigation purposes by 2035. The law also eases authorization of water storage infrastructure by eliminating mandatory public meetings, replacing them with permanent information sessions.
Monique Barbut is the third Minister of Ecology to resign under President Emmanuel Macron's administration. She follows Nicolas Hulot and François de Rugy. Barbut served for approximately nine months, from October 12, 2025, to July 22, 2026, without successfully advancing a pro-environment agenda at the highest levels of government.
The French Parliament definitively adopted an emergency agricultural law on July 21, 2026, which includes provisions to conditionally reintroduce two neonicotinoid pesticides: acetamiprid and flupyradifurone. These pesticides were previously banned in France but remain authorized in the European Union. The law allows the National Food Safety Agency (Anses) to reauthorize these pesticides for specific agricultural sectors facing difficulties, including hazelnut and sugar beet production.
During her tenure, Monique Barbut had previously threatened to resign over budgetary issues, demanding 'real budgets for adaptation and the Green Fund.' She ultimately secured the maintenance of funding levels she considered necessary, though not avoiding some budget cuts.
Monique Barbut stated that France's 2016 decision to ban acetamiprid was based on the precautionary principle and available scientific expertise. She argued that ongoing scientific studies continue to raise concerns about the pesticides' effects on human health and the environment, making the precautionary principle more relevant than ever. She characterized the government's reversal as 'the environmental step back too many.'
Monique Barbut, Minister of Ecological Transition, announced her resignation on July 22, 2026, effective immediately. She formally notified Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu of her decision after the Parliament's adoption of the emergency agricultural law. Barbut opposed the reintroduction of acetamiprid and flupyradifurone pesticides, arguing that the government had broken its commitment to exclude pesticide measures from the legislation and to prevent debate on their removal.
Health agencies warn reintroduced pesticides pose cancer and environmental pollution risks.
French Assembly passes emergency bill reintroducing banned neonicotinoid pesticides acetamiprid and flupyradifurone.
Constitutional Council to decide within 30 days on opposition challenge to emergency agricultural law.
French ecological minister resigns over government's pesticide reauthorization, citing environmental principles.