Supreme Court Weighs Revival of Asylum Metering at US-Mexico Border
The Supreme Court hears arguments on reviving asylum metering, ruled unconstitutional in 2021 and expanded under Trump's first term.
Event / Politics
The US Supreme Court heard oral arguments on whether the Trump administration can revive the 'metering' policy limiting daily asylum applicants at the US-Mexico border. Originally used under Obama and expanded under Trump's first term, the policy was rescinded by Biden in 2021 after courts found it unlawful. The administration defends it as a valid border management tool, while opponents argue it violates federal law and caused a humanitarian crisis.
2026-08-19 to 2026-11-16 · UTC publication dates
Coverage begins 25 Mar, 01:54 UTC
Follow the documented timeline or explore the related reporting.
The metering policy was first implemented during the Obama administration in response to large numbers of Haitians arriving at the San Diego–Tijuana crossing. It was expanded to all U.S.-Mexico border crossings during Trump's first term, then ended in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic. President Biden formally rescinded it in 2021.
At the beginning of his second term, President Trump ordered a wider suspension of the US asylum system, going beyond the metering policy that is at issue in the current Supreme Court case.
The metering case is among several immigration-related suits the Supreme Court is considering during its current term. Others include the Trump administration's effort to end birthright citizenship for children born in the US to parents present illegally, and the administration's attempt to remove legal protections for migrants fleeing instability and armed conflict.
During Trump's first term, migrants who were turned away under the metering policy settled in makeshift camps in Mexico while waiting for a chance to seek asylum, a situation described by advocates as a humanitarian crisis. The Associated Press documented thousands of immigrants on waiting lists when the policy was in effect in 2019.
The 'metering' policy restricts the number of migrants who can present themselves at a U.S. port of entry to apply for asylum on any given day. The legal dispute centers on the meaning of 'arrive in' under the Immigration and Nationality Act: the Justice Department contends it applies only to those already on US soil, while immigration attorneys argue it covers anyone presenting at a port of entry.
In 2021, U.S. District Judge Cynthia Bashant ruled that the metering policy violated migrants' constitutional rights and a federal law requiring officials to screen anyone arriving at the border seeking asylum. The ruling was affirmed by a divided 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, though nearly half of the full court's judges voted to rehear the case.
The US Supreme Court heard oral arguments on whether the Trump administration should be allowed to revive the immigration practice known as 'metering,' which limits the number of migrants who can apply for asylum at the U.S.-Mexico border at any given time. Some conservative justices appeared receptive to the Justice Department's argument, while others questioned the justiciability of the case given the policy is not currently in effect.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson raised concerns during oral arguments about the justiciability of the metering case, noting that the policy is not currently in effect and that the Court was being asked to rule on hypothetical past and future applications rather than an active policy.
The Trump administration's Justice Department argued before the Supreme Court that metering is a 'critical tool' used by administrations of both parties and should remain available for future use. Assistant to the Solicitor General Vivek Suri described it as telling migrants that a port of entry is at capacity and asking them to return another day.
The Supreme Court hears arguments on reviving asylum metering, ruled unconstitutional in 2021 and expanded under Trump's first term.