France Challenges China Over Execution Procedural Safeguards
France protested procedural safeguards in Chan's execution; China defended equal legal application.
Event / Security
International tensions over French nationals sentenced to death in China and executed, raising concerns about capital punishment practices and procedural fairness in the Chinese legal system.
2026-08-19 to 2026-11-16 · UTC publication dates
Coverage begins 5 Apr, 13:08 UTC
Follow the documented timeline or explore the related reporting.
The Chinese Embassy in Paris issued a statement asserting that China treats defendants of all nationalities equally and handles all cases impartially and strictly in accordance with the law, in response to French criticism of the execution.
The French Foreign Ministry expressed consternation over the execution and specifically criticized that Chan's legal defense did not have access to the final court hearing, which the ministry characterized as a violation of his rights.
Chan Thao Phoumy, a 62-year-old French citizen, was executed in Guangzhou, China, after being convicted of drug trafficking. He had been sentenced to death by a Chinese court in 2010 and remained on death row for more than 15 years before the execution was carried out.
French authorities made clemency appeals to Chinese authorities on behalf of Chan Thao Phoumy prior to his execution, but these appeals were not granted and the execution proceeded.
The French Ministry of Foreign Affairs reiterated France's opposition to capital punishment in all circumstances everywhere and called for its universal abolition. This position was reaffirmed in response to the execution of Chan Thao Phoumy.
Chan Thao Phoumy, a 62-year-old French national born in Laos, was executed by Chinese authorities in Guangzhou on April 4, 2026. He had been sentenced to death in August 2010 for manufacturing, transporting, smuggling, and trafficking methamphetamine. He spent approximately 21 years in detention from his arrest in 2005 until his execution.
Before Chan Thao Phoumy's execution, the last known executions of French citizens abroad occurred on April 28, 1983, in Harare, Zimbabwe, when Gervais Boutanquoi (34 years old) and Marc Chemouil (26 years old) were hanged for murder of a German national after their appeals for clemency were rejected.
Following Chan Thao Phoumy's execution, three French nationals remain under death sentences: Nora Lalam condemned in Algeria in 2005 under unclear circumstances; Stéphane Aït Idir and Redouane Hamadi condemned in Morocco in 1995 for involvement in the 1994 Marrakech bombing and incarcerated for approximately 30 years.
According to Amnesty International's 2024 report, China is the country with the highest number of executions worldwide. The organization estimates that thousands of people are sentenced to death and executed each year in China. China does not publish official statistics on capital punishment, classifying them as state secrets.
The French Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a statement expressing consternation over the execution, noting that French authorities had mobilized to obtain clemency for humanitarian reasons. The ministry particularly regretted that the defense had not been granted access to the final court hearing, which it characterized as a violation of the defendant's rights.
Chan Thao Phoumy was accused of being part of a network that produced several tons of methamphetamine in China between 1999 and 2003. The network operated primarily in Guangdong province and expanded to Henan province. The case involved approximately 89 arrests and the seizure of 16 clandestine laboratories producing heroin and methamphetamine, with seized materials valued at approximately 100 million yuan (about 14.8 million US dollars).
Serge Atlaoui, a French national condemned to death in Indonesia in 2007, was transferred to France in February 2025 following a diplomatic agreement. His death sentence was commuted to 30 years imprisonment, and he was released from prison in July 2025.
France protested procedural safeguards in Chan's execution; China defended equal legal application.
Three French nationals currently face death sentences abroad in countries where capital punishment remains in effect.
French national executed in China for involvement in drug trafficking network operating 1999-2003.