Defense seeks investigation into juror who deadlocked Clancy trial
Defense seeks investigation into holdout juror Michael Desronvil; juror publicly defends himself and hires attorney.
Event / Politics
Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial
Ongoing legal proceedings in the Lindsay Clancy triple homicide case, including trial developments, jury deliberations, and procedural issues.
1 reported locations
Daily activity
25 articles0 articles
2026-09-09 to 2026-10-31 · UTC publication dates
Coverage begins 9 Sept, 08:30 UTC
Follow the documented timeline or explore the related reporting.
What happened
Jury foreperson reports holdout juror acknowledged reasonable doubt but refused insanity verdict
The foreperson of the Clancy jury stated that the lone holdout juror eventually acknowledged having reasonable doubt about criminal responsibility, but then refused to vote for a not-guilty-by-reason-of-insanity verdict. The foreperson said she began filling out verdict forms believing they had reached a decision, but the holdout told the group: 'But I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity.'
Nurses on jury used medical knowledge to interpret toxicology evidence
Jurors admitted that nurses serving on the panel used their own medical knowledge to help interpret toxicology evidence during deliberations. When the holdout juror asked a question about medications, the nurses referred to the toxicology report from South Shore Hospital and explained the amounts. One juror stated the holdout 'completely disregarded' the information the nurses provided.
Foreperson wrote note to judge expressing concerns about holdout juror
The jury foreperson wrote a note to Judge William Sullivan expressing concerns about the holdout juror during deliberations. The defense attorney Kevin Reddington requested that the juror be removed, arguing the note indicated the juror refused to follow the judge's instructions on reasonable doubt. Judge Sullivan declined to remove the juror.
Lindsay Clancy mistrial declared after jury deadlocked 11-1
Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on September 4 in the Lindsay Clancy murder case after the jury spent more than six days deliberating and remained deadlocked 11-1. Clancy was charged with killing her three children in January 2023 and pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, arguing she was suffering from postpartum psychosis.
Clancy killed three children at Massachusetts home in January 2023
Lindsay Clancy killed her three young children—Cora (5 years old), Dawson (3 years old), and Callan (8 months old)—at the family's home in Massachusetts in January 2023. After killing her children, Clancy attempted suicide by jumping from a second-story window and survived but was left paralyzed.
Holdout juror rarely examined trial exhibits and rejected request to have judge explain reasonable doubt again
Jurors reported that the holdout juror would not interact with the trial exhibit cart and did not sufficiently engage with the panel. The jurors also revealed they rejected the holdout's suggestion to ask the judge to explain the concept of reasonable doubt again, with one juror recalling: 'And we were like, No, we have it in front of us. We don't need that.'
Jury deliberations became so heated that alternate jurors could hear arguments
The three jurors who broke their silence reported that disagreements during deliberations became so intense that the six alternate jurors could hear them and believed the panel was fighting. Despite the conflict, the jurors said they were determined to continue deliberating and reach a verdict.
Jurors criticized prosecution for harsh presentation lacking character witnesses
Jurors offered criticism of the prosecution's presentation of the case. One juror said she found it 'harsh—very, very harsh.' Another questioned why prosecutors had not presented character witnesses regarding whether Clancy was a bad mother, saying 'I found it to be biased.' The foreperson stated that evidence showed Clancy loved her children.
Holdout juror focused on killings rather than legal question of criminal responsibility
One juror stated that the holdout juror repeatedly returned to the fact that Clancy had killed her children, saying 'He had the hardest time getting off the fact that Lindsay viciously killed her children.' The other jurors tried to focus on the legal question of criminal responsibility, which was the actual case issue.
Read the coverage
2 alternative perspectives
Mistrial ends Clancy case; jury deadlocked 11-1 on insanity verdict
Mistrial declared after 11-1 jury deadlock; Patrick Clancy forgives, remarries, and pursues healthcare accountability.
Social media conspiracy theories emerge about Patrick Clancy's involvement
Unverified conspiracy theories about Patrick Clancy circulate on social media despite verified trial facts.
Family rebuilds after trial: forgiveness, foundation, and moving forward
Patrick Clancy remarries, forgives, and establishes foundation to address systemic healthcare failures.
Mistrial concludes after jury deadlocks on insanity verdict
Mistrial declared after jury deadlocks 11-1; Patrick Clancy remarries and forgives; malpractice lawsuits filed.
Undiagnosed postpartum psychosis emerges as accountability focus in Clancy case
Undiagnosed postpartum psychosis and malpractice lawsuits highlight healthcare accountability gaps in the Clancy case.
Patrick Clancy moves forward: forgiveness, remarriage after tragedy
Patrick Clancy grants first interview stating forgiveness and announces remarriage to Dr. Rachel Denis.
Mistrial declared in Clancy case after jury deadlock
Mistrial declared after jury deadlocked 11-1 on insanity verdict, with one juror blocking consensus despite acknowledging reasonable doubt.
Trial evidence disputes whether Clancy was mentally capable during crimes
Jury split over whether defendant's apparent coherency proved she could be held criminally responsible.
Jury dysfunction emerges: holdout juror recreated crime, ignored instructions
Deliberating juror recreated crime method and ignored reasonable doubt instructions, causing mistrial.
Court examines how exercise bands were used in January 2023 killings
Trial evidence documented exercise bands as the cause of death in the three children's killings.
One juror's unexplained vote halts Lindsay Clancy trial proceedings
One juror's unexplained holdout vote deadlocked the jury 11-1, forcing a mistrial in the Clancy case.